Yes, they can—especially when the design asks people to make a quick decision without giving them clear clues. I’ve watched people stand in front of a multi-compartment bin, lift one lid, peek inside, then try another because the labels were small, the colors didn’t match the local recycling scheme, or the lid didn’t obviously correspond to the compartment below. When someone is in a hurry or carrying a coffee and a bag, that moment of hesitation often ends with everything going into the nearest opening. That’s not really a people problem; it’s a design and communication problem.
The separate lids themselves aren’t automatically confusing. They become confusing when the bin has too many compartments, inconsistent colors, vague icons, or text that only makes sense to people who already know the rules. They also create a tactile issue: if each lid must be opened by hand, people may avoid touching them or may open the wrong one by accident. In places where bins are dirty or crowded, that small friction matters.
Good bins reduce the guesswork. Clear pictograms on both the lid and the body, color coding that matches local collection, simple multilingual labels, distinctive openings, and consistent placement across a city all help. Fewer, better-defined streams are usually better than a rainbow of lids. If a bin still leaves people unsure, most will default to general waste—so the real test is whether the design makes the right choice the easy choice. In short, separate lids can confuse people, but they don’t have to. Clear cues, consistency, and a little empathy for someone with full hands make the difference.