That's a common and frustrating problem! Winter can be brutal on standard outdoor bins. When plastic gets cold, it becomes brittle and loses flexibility, leading to cracks from simple pressure or even from the waste inside freezing and expanding.
For a truly freeze-resistant can, you need to look for specific features. First, focus on the material. Avoid thin, basic plastics. Instead, look for heavy-duty, commercial-grade resins or plastics specifically advertised as "arctic-grade" or "all-weather." These are formulated to remain flexible and impact-resistant in extremely low temperatures.
The design is also crucial. A seamless or rotational-molded construction is superior because it has no weak points or seams that can split under stress. Cans with thick walls provide better insulation and structural integrity. Some advanced models even have a flexible, rubber-like bottom or collar designed to withstand expansion from freezing contents.
Brands like Rubbermaid Commercial or Toter often offer product lines built for durability in municipal use, which translates well to harsh winters. While metal cans don't crack, they can dent and their lids may freeze shut.
My recommendation? Invest in a heavy-duty, rotationally-molded plastic can from a reputable brand. Check the product specifications for temperature ratings, and look for keywords like "frost-proof" or "cold-crack resistant." It might cost more upfront, but it will save you from replacing a cracked bin every few winters. A good tip is to also lightly coat the lid's seal with cooking spray in late fall to help prevent it from freezing shut.