Honestly, in most cities, urban trash cans hold up pretty well in freezing temperatures if they’re built for cold weather. The ones that fail tend to be cheap plastic bins, poorly sealed steel units, or cans with hinges and latches that weren’t designed for winter. Cold alone usually isn’t the main problem; it’s the mix of ice, road salt, freeze-thaw cycles, snowplows, and delayed collection.
Plastic cans can get brittle below freezing, so a hard hit from a plow or a heavy bag can crack the base or lid. Metal cans are stronger, but hinges, latches, and bolts can freeze up or corrode faster when salt is around. Heavy-duty composite and concrete bins usually handle cold well, though moisture can get into small cracks and expand when it freezes.
The most common winter issues I see are lids frozen shut, bags frozen to the inside, and ice blocking drainage holes. A can with a smooth liner, good drainage, and a lid that’s easy to open with gloves on performs much better. Weighted bases also help on windy, icy streets.
Maintenance matters as much as material. Cities need to clear snow and ice around the can, avoid overfilling, inspect hinges and latches, and use de-icing methods that won’t damage the coating. Collection crews may also need to knock ice loose before emptying. Overall, a well-designed urban trash can will survive winter fine; a cheap one will show its weaknesses fast.