Honestly, they can—but the lids themselves usually aren’t the real problem. What confuses people is ambiguity: two or three compartments, separate lids, but labels that are small, worn, or placed where you only see them after you’ve already opened the wrong one. In a hurry, people rely on shape, color, and position more than text. If every lid looks the same and the openings don’t signal what belongs where, separate lids can make users pause or guess.
I’ve noticed this most near train stations and food courts, where people are walking fast and holding a coffee cup or wrapper. A single lid with clear divided openings can feel simpler, but separate lids can work well when the design is consistent: color-coded lids, simple icons, physical openings shaped for bottles or cups, and a label right at eye level. Feedback matters too—if the bin rejects the wrong item or if the opening is obviously too small for a pizza box, users correct themselves quickly.
So my answer is: yes, poorly designed separate-lid bins confuse users, especially when they mix too many rules with weak visual cues. But separate lids are not inherently a bad idea. They reduce cross-contamination and can make recycling cleaner when the system is simple, visible, and consistent across the city. The key is to design for split-second decisions, not for people who will stop and read a manual.