I’d treat this as a design and operations problem, not just a “tell people not to do it” problem. If a liner is easy to see, grab, and pull out, someone will eventually take it. The goal is to make removal slow, awkward, and less rewarding.
Start with the bin itself. The best long-term fix is often a public trash can with an integrated rigid inner container or a reusable hard liner that gets emptied directly. There’s no disposable bag to steal, and crews can wash and reuse the insert. If you must use disposable liners, choose a bin with a locking bag-retention ring, a hinged lid, and a service door that opens with a master key. Use tamper-resistant screws or a steel band rather than zip ties, which are easy to cut. Just make sure collection staff can open the bin quickly—security that slows down crews usually gets defeated or ignored.
Reduce the liner’s resale value. Plain black bags are attractive because they look useful; municipally marked, printed, or brightly colored liners are less appealing to steal and easier to trace. Some cities also use perforated or branded bags so they can’t be quietly reused elsewhere. Pair that with clear signage like “Municipal liner—not for public use” and a simple reporting line. Signs alone won’t stop determined thieves, but they help neighbors understand the issue and report patterns.
Adjust operations. Empty bins before liners get heavy and full, because a full bag is easier to grab and more valuable. Work with your waste hauler on frequency and bag type. If theft is concentrated at certain spots, try a pilot: secure rings on a few bins, liner-free inserts on others, and compare cost, cleanliness, and theft reports. Add lighting or legal, well-posted cameras only where appropriate; reducing access is usually cheaper and more effective than surveillance.
Finally, involve the people who use and service the bins. Talk with public works, property managers, collection crews, and neighborhood groups. Ask crews which bins get tampered with and why. A mix of better bin design, marked liners, smart emptying schedules, and a switch to reusable inner containers will solve most of this problem without turning every trash can into a fortress.