Short answer: sometimes, but not as a stand-alone fix. Smaller openings on public trash cans can reduce illegal dumping by making it harder for people to cram in household bags, shop waste, or bulky items. That’s the idea behind anti-dumping bins: they accept everyday litter, not someone else’s entire week of rubbish. In places where public bins were being used as free disposal points, a restrictive aperture can help cut volume and contamination.
But the effect is usually local and behavior-dependent. Research and city experience are mixed. If a bin is hard to use, people may leave bags beside it, toss litter on the ground, or find another open bin. So a smaller opening can simply move the problem a few meters away. It can also create accessibility issues for people with limited grip strength, parents with strollers, or anyone carrying something awkward. That’s why design matters: foot pedals, clear signage, enough capacity, and frequent collection all affect whether people use the bin properly.
I’d see smaller openings as a useful nudge, not a complete policy. They work best when the city also provides convenient legal alternatives—bulky waste pickup, recycling centers, clear rules, and enforcement against serious dumping. Without those, restrictive bins can feel like a barrier rather than a solution. So yes, they can cut down on some illegal dumping, but only as part of a wider waste management strategy.