That's an excellent question, and you've hit on a very common frustration for many municipalities and property managers. The short answer is yes, metal urban trash cans are generally a far superior option for winter durability compared to standard plastic ones. Here’s a more detailed look at why.
The core issue with many plastic bins is that they become brittle in freezing temperatures. The constant cycle of being knocked over, the pressure of compacted trash, and impacts from plows or equipment can cause cracks and splits. Once cracked, they are useless and need replacement. Metal cans, typically made from galvanized steel or aluminum, don't suffer from this brittleness. They can withstand sub-zero temperatures without compromising their structural integrity, handling bumps and impacts that would shatter plastic.
Beyond just not cracking, metal cans offer other winter advantages. Their weight makes them less likely to tip over in strong winds. They are also more resistant to damage from snow removal equipment. While metal does conduct cold, a well-designed can with proper drainage holes won't hold meltwater that can freeze and cause issues.
There are considerations, of course. Metal cans have a higher upfront cost. They can be prone to rust if the galvanized coating is severely scratched and not maintained. In coastal areas, salt corrosion is a factor. However, their lifespan—often 10-15 years or more versus 2-5 for a plastic bin in harsh conditions—often makes them more cost-effective in the long run.
For the deepest freezes, look for cans made from high-grade, thick-gauge steel with a robust powder-coated or galvanized finish. Aluminum is lighter and rust-proof but can dent more easily. In summary, if you're tired of the annual replacement cycle of cracked plastic bins, investing in quality metal urban trash cans is a smart, winter-proof strategy for durability and long-term savings.